Ownership·Report·By Arthur Lewis·

Sutton United Add Four Directors Ahead of Fan Share Offer

Sutton United have named four new directors as they prepare to offer shares to supporters through Republic Europe. The appointments follow a series of share issues recording about £1.57m of consideration between February and August 2026, alongside changes to the club's rules on electing directors and calling votes on their continuation.

TL;DR
  • Costa Alexiou, Mark Boulter, Steve Dunne and Councillor Trish Fivey will join the board this month, subject to Independent Football Regulator checks and formal approvals.
  • The announcement follows a new chief financial officer, a new general manager and club secretary, and Tim Allison stepping back from his executive roles to concentrate on the board, all within ten days.
  • The club is preparing a share offer on Republic Europe called "The Future is Amber". It expects to raise £300,000 to £400,000 and says it plans no further raises. No launch date, target or share price has been announced.
  • Allotment returns record about £1.57m paid for new A shares issued between February and August 2026.
  • ACV Sports Ventures LLC, whose ultimate beneficial owner is Gary Otto, holds between 50% and 75%. In March 2026 it held 83% of the A shares, and Civitas Sutton LLC about 12% of the company.
  • New articles adopted in April require every director to stand for re-election each year, and allow any shareholder with 10% of the votes to call a meeting to vote on a director's continuation.
  • Accounts to 31 May 2025 show net assets of £1,318,071, up from net liabilities of £1,597,206, an improvement driven by share issues that included the conversion of £2.21m of loan notes.

Sutton United have named four new directors as they prepare to offer shares to supporters through Republic Europe. The appointments follow a series of share issues recording about £1.57m of consideration between February and August 2026, alongside changes to the club's rules on electing directors and calling votes on their continuation.

The new board

Sutton announced on 16 November that four new members would join the board "this month (subject to Independent Football Regulator checks and formal approvals)". Costa Alexiou is chief executive of PMY Capital and co-founder of Civitas Collective. Mark Boulter is director of commercial technology at McLaren Racing. Steve Dunne is a senior director at Sage, with previous roles at Workday and WPP. Councillor Trish Fivey is a Sutton councillor, a former mayor and a long-standing supporter.

The club describes the group as "the new Board", "deliberately assembled" to bring together experience in commercial growth, technology, elite sport, business and community leadership, and as part of "a broader evolution of Sutton United's governance and leadership". It says further work is under way on the club's longer-term strategy. The statement does not say whether any existing directors will step down, and none of the four yet appears on the Companies House register. The current board is Bruce Elliott, the chairman, with Tim Allison, Martin Copus, Benjamin Hautt, Michael Joyce and Gary Otto.

The board announcement completes a reorganisation that began earlier in the month. On 6 November Tim Allison, who became full-time chief operating officer in 2021, moved out of that role and the club secretary's post to focus on his board responsibilities. On 10 November the club appointed Ross Jones, who has worked closely with it for two years, as chief financial officer, and Harry Dunne, previously with the Sutton United Foundation, as general manager and club secretary.

Who owns Sutton United

Sutton United Football Club Limited is controlled by ACV Sports Ventures LLC, a Delaware company that Companies House records as holding between 50% and 75% of the shares. The club's governance page names Gary Otto, a director, as its ultimate beneficial owner. The same page records Civitas Sutton LLC as holding more than 10%, and supporters also hold shares.

The most recent detailed picture is the confirmation statement made on 5 March 2026, which is a snapshot at that date; further shares have been issued since. At 5 March ACV held 220,493 A shares and 13,962 ordinary shares, about 71% of the 331,743 shares then in issue. Civitas Sutton LLC held 34,064 A shares and 6,975 ordinary shares, about 12%. MBuzzSport LLC, a UAE company that ceased to be a person with significant control in May 2025, still held 9,500 ordinary shares, and the Sutton United Supporters' Society held 74. More than two hundred other shareholders, most of them individual supporters, held the remainder in small amounts.

Who is Gary Otto?

Gary Otto is Sutton United's controlling shareholder, through ACV Sports Ventures, a Los Angeles-based investment company the club describes as his. When the club announced his arrival, it described him as a South African-born real estate developer and ACV as its second major corporate shareholder, after MBuzzSport. He joined the board in February 2021, and ACV has been recorded at Companies House as a person with significant control since November 2021.

In a supporters' podcast interview published in July 2024, Otto said he grew up in South Africa and moved to the United States in 1986 on a two-year contract with a chartered accountancy firm, and has lived there since. He said he first invested in Sutton in December 2020, after a dinner with the board and a representative of MBuzzSport during a trip to London, and that he came in as a minority shareholder. After the club's promotion to the Football League in 2021, he said, he funded upgrades to the pitch, floodlights, ticketing, capacity and seating that other shareholders could not, which diluted their holdings and in time gave him a controlling interest. He described football as one of the worst businesses in the world and his involvement as a long-term commitment, not one made for a financial return.

The register records ACV as holding more than 50% but less than 75% of the shares, and in March 2026 it held 83% of the A shares created in the most recent rounds of funding.

A year of share issues

The register records new shares issued almost every month. The company has two classes: ordinary shares with a nominal value of £50 and A shares with a nominal value of £1. A variation filed in April 2026 confirmed that both classes carry full rights and rank equally in all respects.

Nominal share capital rose by £244,195 between the allotment of 31 August 2025 and that of 31 August 2026. That understates the sums involved, because the A shares have been issued above their £1 nominal value. The allotment returns for February to August 2026 record about £1.57m paid in total.

Allotment date A shares issued Price per share Recorded as paid
28 February 2026 2,890 £22.50 £65,025
28 February 2026 2,169 £2.30 £4,995
28 February 2026 17,286 £4.35 £75,145
28 February 2026 115,351 £5.74 £662,112
31 March 2026 10,134 £12.34 £125,012
31 March 2026 10 £25.00 £250
30 April 2026 17,915 £7.31 £131,002
31 May 2026 20,004 £6.95 £138,994
30 June 2026 22,165 £6.58 £145,897
31 August 2026 34,971 £6.22 £217,499

A further 26 ordinary shares were issued at their £50 nominal value on 1 March 2026. The returns do not name the subscribers, and the amounts above are the consideration recorded on the returns rather than cash receipts confirmed in the club's accounts.

The A share class was created in May 2025, when the club issued shares recorded at about £2.64m. The accounts for that year say those shares were issued "on converting existing loan notes to shares as well as additional cash deposits". The balance sheet shows £2.21m of convertible loan notes at May 2024 reduced to £19,150 a year later. That conversion turned existing debt into equity and is separate from the 2026 issues above.

The fan share offer

On 8 July the club announced "The Future is Amber", an investment campaign on Republic Europe inviting supporters and private investors to buy a stake. Republic Europe approved the campaign as a financial promotion on 6 July. The July announcement said money raised would fund "continued commitments to the playing squad, infrastructure upgrades, and operational excellence".

An FAQ published on 17 August is more specific. Investors would buy newly issued shares in Sutton United Football Club Limited, and "100% of the raise" would go on stadium improvements, training facilities and operational excellence. Raised funds would "only be used for agreed projects", with the playing budget benefiting only indirectly, for instance through income from training ground hire or improved event spaces. Based on pre-registration and Republic Europe's modelling, the club expects to raise £300,000 to £400,000 and says it will name a target before launch. Asked whether further raises are likely, it answered: "No, this is the only one planned." Investor perks would range from a pin badge and scarf to a season-long hospitality table. The club has not yet announced a launch date, a target or the price at which shares will be offered.

New rules for directors

At a general meeting on 30 April 2026, members adopted new articles of association. Every director is now required to retire each year and stand for re-election at a general meeting, and the chairman's position must be ratified by the same vote. In addition, any shareholder or group of shareholders representing 10% or more of the votes of the company can call a general meeting at any time to hold a vote on whether a director should continue in post.

The right is to call that vote, not to remove a director directly, and the outcome depends on the shareholder vote that follows. Even so, the changes give shareholders an annual say over the whole board and allow any holder above 10% to put a director's position to a vote between annual meetings. On the March figures, ACV and Civitas Sutton LLC each cleared that threshold on their own.

The finances

Sutton files small-company accounts without a profit and loss account, so turnover, wages and the operating result are not public. The accounts to 31 May 2025 show net assets of £1,318,071, against net liabilities of £1,597,206 a year earlier, an improvement of £2,915,277. Share capital and premium together rose by about £3.7m in the year, while the accumulated deficit grew by £794,382 to £4,840,738. The recovery in the balance sheet therefore came from equity transactions, including the conversion of existing loan notes, and not from any demonstrated trading profit. Cash at the year end was £58,163, and the average number of employees was 90.

The going-concern note is direct about how the club has been funded. It says the company has met its obligations since the year end and expects to continue doing so, and that it "has primarily achieved this with the issue of significant additional share capital". After the year end the club signed a £340,000 contract for a new pavilion, with £288,000 of Football Foundation funding in place. The Football Foundation holds charges over the club's leasehold interests at the Borough Sports Ground and Collingwood Recreation Ground, and the English Sports Council holds a further charge, all created in 2021.

The ground also hosts Crystal Palace Women in the WSL under a long-term agreement, which The Pyramid's Burger Index visit in October noted alongside a new hybrid pitch. The commercial terms of that arrangement have not been disclosed.

What comes next

The four appointments still need regulator clearance, and the register will show when they take effect and whether anyone leaves the board. The Republic Europe campaign has yet to set its target and price. The next accounts, for the year to 31 May 2026, are due by 28 February 2027 and will be the first to reflect the 2026 share issues.

Frequently asked

Who is Gary Otto?

Sutton United's controlling shareholder. A South African-born businessman who has lived in the United States since 1986, he controls the club through ACV Sports Ventures, first invested in December 2020 and joined the board in February 2021.

Who owns Sutton United?

ACV Sports Ventures LLC holds between 50% and 75% of the shares, and the club names Gary Otto as its ultimate beneficial owner. Civitas Sutton LLC held approximately 12% in the March 2026 confirmation statement, with the remaining shares distributed among other corporate and individual shareholders, including supporters.

Who are Sutton United's new directors?

Costa Alexiou of PMY Capital and Civitas Collective, Mark Boulter of McLaren Racing, Steve Dunne of Sage, and Councillor Trish Fivey, a former mayor of Sutton. Their appointments are subject to Independent Football Regulator checks and formal approvals.

Who is Costa Alexiou?

Sutton United describes him as chief executive of PMY Capital and co-founder of Civitas Collective.

What is The Future is Amber?

A share offer on Republic Europe through which supporters can buy newly issued shares in the club. It has not yet launched, and the club expects to raise £300,000 to £400,000.

What will the money be spent on?

The club says all of it will go on stadium improvements, training facilities and operational excellence, and that funds will only be used for agreed projects.

How much have shareholders put in recently?

Allotment returns record about £1.57m paid for new shares issued between February and August 2026. The returns do not name the subscribers.

Can shareholders remove directors?

Under the club's amended articles, directors must stand for annual re-election. Shareholders controlling at least 10% of the votes can require a meeting to vote on a director's continuation, but removal itself requires the appropriate shareholder decision.

Is Sutton United profitable?

The filed accounts do not disclose the profit and loss account, so the club's operating result cannot be independently assessed from the published statements. Its accumulated deficit increased by £794,382, while new share capital and premium improved the balance sheet.

Sources

Company filing
Club statement
Press
The Pyramid

Read next

Follow the money

Football’s money, all the way down — every week, free.

Ownership, accounts and the real cost of a matchday, from the Premier League to tier ten. No spam, unsubscribe any time.

Subscribers can also enter The Pyramid 1st Season Giveaway.

More from the Burger Index